Showing posts with label Heisman Trophy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Heisman Trophy. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 8, 2015

Week 1 Review

Some quick thoughts after the 1st week of the college football season.

Michigan is improved, but Harbaugh still has a lot of work to do.  Last year the Wolverines lost at home to Utah 26-10, with the Utes scoring the final 16 points for the win.  Michigan lost this year, but put up a fight the whole way.  Losing 24-17 on the road and were a recovered onside kick away from making the game REAL interesting.

Utah could be really good if they found some more play makers on the offensive side of the ball.  Devontae Booker is the only threat the Utes have and he is a good one, but they need more.  Booker carried the ball 22 times and scored on the ground.  He also was their leading receiver with 7 catches in week 1 vs Michigan.

TCU got a road win versus a Power 5 team, but they didn’t look very impressive in doing so.  It is just one game, but the Horned Frogs couldn’t finish drives and had to settle for field goals on too many drives.  They certainly didn’t look like what you would expect from the 2nd best team in the country.

Duke and David Cutcliffe have found their quarterback.  Cutcliffe has been a quarterback guru everywhere he has coached but has yet to find one at Duke, until now.  Thomas Sirk made his debut with the Blue Devils Thursday night against Tulane and the junior QB was 27-40 for 289 and 2 scores.  He also ran the ball 15 times for 68 yards.

New Baylor QB Seth Russell throws a really nice ball; he has great touch on the deep ball.  It is only a 1 game sample, but it looks like the Baylor offense won’t miss much with Russell stepping in for Bryce Petty.  Russell actually adds a little more athleticism to the quarterback position for the Bears.

Hawaii and Colorado was a perfect example of why a preseason game in college football is not a terrible idea.  The two quarterbacks combined to go 42-78 and just 360 yard.  It also had 18 punts, 14 penalties and five turnovers and was utterly unwatchable.

Stop FCS games!  Yes every year you get teams like Washington State and Kansas that lose to the FCS, but you also get games like Georgia Tech beating Alcorn State 69-6 with GT running for 476 yards and Ole Miss beating Tennessee-Martin 76-3 which included a 55-0 lead and Mississippi THROWING a touchdown pass in the 4th quarter.  Those games need to stop.

Continue playing on the road against Group of 5 teams if you are a Power 5 team.  It creates the chance of upsets and it immediately gives these lower level FBS teams a showcase home game that the players and fans can look forward to.  In the opening week only we saw teams like Temple beat Penn State at home.  Western Michigan playing with in-state foe Michigan State into the 4th quarter and Central Michigan leading Oklahoma State in the 2nd half before falling short.  Those games are great for the little guys and a real challenge for the big boys.  A win-win for everybody.

Malik Zaire is fun to watch run Brian Kelly’s offense at Notre Dame.  It seems to be pretty clear why Everett Golson transferred out of Notre Dame, because he was good, but Zaire has the potential to do some special things for the Irish this season.  Zaire went 19-22 for 313 and 3 scores in the opener against Texas.

Notre Dame is either really good or Texas is absolutely awful.  It reality it is probably somewhere in between.  Charlie Strong is in year 2 of a huge rebuild at Texas, so nobody expected a CFB Playoff bid, but I would imagine that the fan-base didn’t expect the worst loss to open the season since 1988 (@BYU 47-6).

I loved watching the aggressive play and play-calling of the Temple defense against Penn State.  Temple is a team that is full of players that didn’t get recruited by Penn State and despite being overmatched at almost every position that didn’t change their style of play and it paid off, limiting Penn State to just 54 yards in their final 12 drives of the game.

The Penn State offensive line is awful.  I really like Christian Hackenberg and I would love to see what he could do if his O-Line could keep him clean, but that doesn’t look like it will happen in his time at Penn State.  Hackenberg was sacked 10 times by Temple on Saturday.  Some are thinking that Hackenberg could be the top QB selected in next year’s NFL draft.  That will only happen if he survives this season.

Oregon lost the Heisman Trophy winner and 2nd overall pick in quarterback Marcus Mariotta, yet the Ducks didn’t miss a beat in their 61-42 win over Eastern Washington.  Oregon racked up 731 yards and 34 first downs on offense.  That includes running for 485 and 6 touchdowns.  They also didn’t lose their quick score attach either.  All of the Ducks scoring drives were under 3 minutes except their final score in the 4th quarter, that one lasted 3:20.

Tons of stars lost for the season already in just one week.  Quarterbacks Taysom Hill (BYU) and Terrel Hunt (Syracuse), running backs Tarean Folston (Notre Dame) and James Conner (Pitt) and defensive lineman Eddie Vanderdoes (UCLA) are all highly regarded players that are done for the season already due to injuries.  We also have All-American linebacker Scooby Wright from Arizona, safety Mike Caputo from Wisconsin, wide receiver Mike Williams from Clemson and Virginia Tech quarterback Michael Brewer out for a considerable amount of time with lesser injuries.

Will Muschamp joining the coaching staff at Auburn is a very good thing.  We all know that Gus Malzahn knows offense and can put up some points, but now he has a defense behind it.  Muschamp, the former Florida head coach has always been a great defensive mind and now he able to focus on just that.  In the opener versus Louisville, Auburn scored 1 defensive touchdown on an 82 yard fumble return in the 1st half and set up another one with a 35 yard interception return in the 2nd half.  Auburn jumped out to a 24-0 3rd quarter lead before Louisville final got on the scoreboard.

Alabama’s running game is crazy good.  The Tide have had guys like Eddie Lacy and Mark Ingram in recent years, but Derrick Henry might be the best of the bunch.  Henry ran for 147 on 13 carries and 3 scores against Wisconsin on Saturday.  His back up Kenyan Drake ran 10 times for 77 yards and a score.  He also had 2 catches for 48 yards.  This 1-2 punch from Alabama is as good as we have seen from the Crimson Tide.

High Octane is illegal in Houston, TX.  Arizona State and the Fighting Todd Graham’s had only 291 yards of offense (3.55 ypp) and two turnovers against Texas A&M Saturday.  Of the Fighting Todd Graham’s 1st 12 drives, they punted 9 times, fumbled twice and scored just one touchdown.

I still love watching Todd Graham lose.  I don’t think that will change any time soon either.

I love watching Penn State lose.  I know that won’t change any time soon.

Hail Mary conversions are fun. 
West Coast teams should never be forced to play noon EST.  Stanford played Northwestern at Noon.  The players woke up at 4:30 to try to make up for the time difference and prepare for the game, it didn’t help.  The Cardinal looked sluggish from the get go.  They finished the game with just 2 field goals and only 240 yards of total offense.  They also turned the ball over twice.

Baker Mayfield showed why he was named the starter for the Oklahoma Sooners after camp.  Mayfield threw for 388 yards and 3 scores in his collegiate debut.  He also ran for another touchdown.  He unseated Trevor Knight who was the returning starter, who accounted for over 3,100 yards and 30 touchdowns in his 1st 2 years at OU.


Josh Rosen looks to be the real thing at UCLA.  The #1 rated quarterback out of high school last year won the starting job at UCLA in fall camp and impressed in his debut.  Rosen threw for 351 and 3 touchdowns, going 28 of 35 in a 34-16 win over Virginia.

Ohio State looked pretty impressive in their opener.  After the Buckeyes got things going they looked unstoppable, and remember they were playing without 4 starters that were suspended.  I still am not sure that Cardale Jones is the best option for the Urban Meyer offense, but he also isn’t a bad option to have.  With their toughest game out of the way, if Ohio State loses at any point in the season it would be a huge upset.

Saturday, December 8, 2012

The Tarnished Trophy


The Heisman Trophy will be awarded tonight for the 77th time in its history.  According to the Heisman Trust Mission Statement, it will be presented to “the outstanding college football player whose performance best exhibits the pursuit of excellence with integrity. Winners epitomize great ability combined with diligence, perseverance, and hard work. The Heisman Trophy Trust ensures the continuation and integrity of this award.”  Reading this was news to me because growing up, I always thought that the Heisman Trophy was awarded to the best player in college football.  Recently, that too has changed to giving the award to the best player on the best team in college football. 

For this reason, the Heisman Trophy, which was once the single greatest individual trophy in all of sports, has now become ordinary.

In all likelihood, Johnny Football, Johnny Manziel to those of you new to this freshman phenom, will win tonight, as he should.  I have no problem with him winning.  My problem is with the player who many think could pull the upset, Manti Te’o.  Now, maybe my issue should be with the Heisman committee and their voters instead of with Te’o himself.  As I said, the Heisman Trophy used to be awarded to the best player in college football who held those traits and qualities mentioned in the Heisman Trust Mission Statement.  Now, they give it to the best player on one of the top ranked teams.

Manti Te’o had a very nice season this year, and did it all with a heavy heart after losing his grandmother and girlfriend within a 24 hour span.  I get that.  That being said, he isn’t the best linebacker in football, let alone the best player in the nation.  He was the middle linebacker on the best defense in the country and averaged just 4.33 solo tackles a game, which does not rank in the top 100 nationally (The NCAA only ranks top 100).  Te’o also ranks 59th in the nation in total tackles with 103.  That is 63 tackles behind the nation’s leader.  As for interceptions, yes, he does have 7 this season, which is more than any other linebacker in the nation, and only 1 other player has more.  That player is Phillip Thomas from Fresno State, who returned 3 of those 8 picks for scores.  Thomas also has more solo tackles than Te’o this year.  Why wasn’t he invited to New York?  If the trophy is given to the best player, one would think Thomas would be invited before Te’o.  No?

Let’s try this blind comparison.

PLAYER A:
Tackles - 103
Sacks - 1.5
Interceptions - 7
Tackles for Loss - 5.5 for 19 yards
QB Hurries - 4
Forced Fumbles - 0
Fumbles Recovered - 2

PLAYER B:
Tackles - 125
Sacks - 5.5
Interceptions - 2
Tackles for Loss - 10.5 for 48 yards
QB Hurries - 8
Forced Fumbles - 6
Fumbles Recovered - 2

Player A is Notre Dame LB and Heisman Finalist Manti Te’o.  Player B is the 2-time Big East Player of the Year, Khaseem Greene, a linebacker from Rutgers.  The numbers speak for themselves.  For what it’s worth, Rutgers allowed 14.25 points per game, good enough for 4th best in the nation, and they finished with a 9-3 record and unranked.

Again, I hate the way this award is now given to the player with the most publicity who plays for a great team.  Nowhere in the Heisman mission statement does it say the “most valuable” or “leader,” yet that is the voters’ current interpretation for the award.

In 1985, Bo Jackson’s senior year at Auburn they finished 8-4 and unranked.  In 1988, Barry Sanders starred on a team outside the Top 10 at Oklahoma State.  Neither of those two players would have won the Heisman Trophy had the voters used the same mentality then, which they use now.  More recently, in one of the biggest Heisman snubs in history, Jason White, the quarterback of the #1 ranked Oklahoma Sooners, was awarded the Heisman over Larry Fitzgerald, star wide receiver of the 8-4 Pitt Panthers. I would love to go back and hear from the voters who voted for White that year over Fitzgerald.

The Heisman is a joke anymore.  It lives off its history and is no longer as prestigious as it once was.  That is unfortunate, because at one point in history, it truly meant something special to win the Heisman Trophy.

Friday, October 16, 2009

RANDOM RANTING

HEISMAN TALK
I like Colt McCoy. I think he is a very entertaining player to watch on Saturdays. But he is not a legit Heisman Trophy candidate.

Before I get into why he is not a legit candidate this year let me say that I think the Heisman Trophy has become one of the biggest joke awards there is in college football. It used to be given to the best player in the nation. Now it is given to the QB of the best team in the nation. Only once this decade has the award gone to a non-quarterback (Reggie Bush, 2005). Only twice this decade has the award gone to a player that was not playing in the BCS National Title game (Tim Tebow, 2007; Carson Palmer, 2002). Now, I do understand that there have also been some very deserving players that have won it in this same time frame, but when you see names like Troy Smith (2006), Jason White (2003), and Chris Weinke (2000) you have to wonder.

All of that being said about the award it would not shock me if Colt McCoy wins the award this year. I would be glad for him (not that he deserves it this year, but I though he should have gotten it last year). There seems to be this underground push to get McCoy the award this year almost as a career achievement award. So lets see if you think he deserves the award this year.

Here are 4 players’ stats this year, you figure out who is most deserving of these three.

PLAYER 1:
67.6% completion percentage
1544 yards
12 TD’s
2 INT’s
179.3 QB Rating

PLAYER 2:
66.7%
1256 yards
13 TD’s
3 INT’s
163.5 QB Rating

PLAYER 3:
73.4%
1410 yards
10 TD’s
6 INT’s
149.2 QB Rating

PLAYER 4:
53.4%
810 yards
7 TD’s
4 INT’s
147.9 QB Rating

PLAYER 1: Jimmy Clausen, Notre Dame
PLAYER 2: Bill Stull, Pitt
PLAYER 3: Colt McCoy
PLAYER 4: BJ Daniels, USF (who made his third career start last night)

As you can see the numbers don’t lie, McCoy is simply not deserving of the award this year. McCoy has throw 6 INT’s this year already, he threw 8 all of last season. He has thrown at least one in every game this season. Although he leads the nation in completion percentage (he set an NCAA mark last year completing over 76%) he ranks way down in many other categories; Touchdowns (28th), Interceptions (25th), 7.7 yards/attempt leaves him 42nd in the nation. These are not numbers of a Heisman Trophy winner.

Let’s look at a couple of guys that do have the numbers so far this season.

Clausen, he leads the nation in QB Rating and yards per attempt. He also is averaging over 300 yards a game, despite missing time with turf toe. He has some signature moments already in three come from behind wins.

Kellen Moore, quarterback at Boise State, has almost as impressive numbers as Clausen, on what I think is a better team that has played tougher competition. Moore has thrown 16 TD’s against just 2 INT’s. He has put up these numbers all while blowing teams out (some good teams) and not getting to throw the ball as much as Clausen does. The sophpomore has attempted more than 30 passes just twice in his six games, while his team has averaged over 38 ppg. Clausen has had over 30 attempts in every game but two, and one of those games he was sidelined much of the 2nd half by injury.

Ryan Williams, running back at Virginia Tech, has 734 yards on the ground and nine touchdowns to start his college career. The freshman back also has 143 yards on just seven catches for the Hokies. He ranks 5th in the nation in yards (12 behind the leader) and 4th in scores.

TOP 50
A lot has been made of the terrible play this season by JaMarcus Russell, but I found one very telling stat that summarizes it all up, his QB rating. QB Rating is a very complicated stat, but it is also a very telling stat. It is used as the standard in comparing and ranking the quarterback position. That being said Russell ranks 50th in the NFL in that stat. Let me remind you that there are only 32 teams in the NFL. JaMarcus has a rating of 47.1. The only starter with a worse rating is Derek Anderson of the Browns who has only started two games so far this season. Other players ahead of him include 1 WR, 3 RB’s and a punter. In fact his numbers are so bad that players with zero completions are close on his tail. If you throw 1 pass and it falls incomplete you have a passer rating of 39.6. Russell has thrown 4 INT’s so far to just 1 TD in 5 games and 121 pass attempts.



WEEKEND PREDICTIONS:
Pitt starts us off tonight traveling to Rutgers. Rutgers is the only team in the Big East that Dave Wannestedt has yet to beat; he is 0-4 against them. Pitt has by far the better talent, but Pitt always loses at least one game every year that they have superior talent against, and have not done that yet this season. Pitt should win this one by about three touchdowns, but I’ll settle for just one. PITT 27-16.

Penn State takes on Minnesota in a barn-burner in the Big Ten, PENN STATE 4-3.

Texas-OU in the Red River Shootout, I like Texas BIG! OU lost too many players from last year and Texas kept everyone. For as hyped as this game normally is, it is very rarely a good game. I think the trend will continue with Texas winning easily, TEXAS 41-28.

Charlie Weis said this week that he believes that this is the first year since he started in South Bend that his player feel that they can beat USC. Let me ask you this, what does that say about Charlie Weis? He coaches at what was the most prestigious place in college football with a team that was absolutely loaded with talent in 2005 and lost to USC on the final play of the game and that team didn't have enough confidence going in to really think they could beat the Trojans? Chalk this up as just another reason Weis should be fired and another reason that Notre Dame will never again be what it once was. USC 31-17.

I like the Phillies and the Angels to win each of their series. In the NL I really don’t care who wins, but I think the Phillies pitching with Lee and Hamels combined with their deep lineup will be too much for LA. In the AL I just simply hate the Yankees so I’m going with the Angels.

My First Rankings of the College Football season will be unveiled next week!